Medicare Supplement

Plan G vs High-Deductible Plan G

High-Deductible Plan G covers the same things as Plan G once you meet a yearly deductible that CMS sets and raises each year. Until then, you pay Medicare-covered costs yourself. In return, premiums are far lower: the Nebraska Department of Insurance's 2026 ranges at age 65 put the high-deductible version well below regular Plan G.

Tax forms, a calculator and a cup of coffee

In short

  • CMS sets the high deductible each year, and it went up again for 2027. After you meet it, the plan pays like regular Plan G.
  • The Part B deductible counts toward the high deductible, along with the Part A deductible and your 20% coinsurance.
  • In Nebraska's 2026 ranges at age 65, even the top High-Deductible Plan G premium sits below the lowest regular Plan G premium.
  • It fits healthy people who can pay the full deductible from savings in a bad year and who bank the premium savings in good years.

Plan G vs High-Deductible Plan G at a glance

FeaturePlan GHigh-Deductible Plan G
Monthly premium, age 65, Nebraska (2026)Higher, with a wide range between companies, per the Nebraska Department of InsuranceMuch lower, with a narrow range, per the Nebraska Department of Insurance
Deductible before the plan paysNone of its own; you pay only the Part B deductibleA yearly high deductible set by CMS
Part B deductibleYou pay it once a yearYou pay it, and it counts toward the high deductible
Part A hospital deductibleCoveredYou pay it until the high deductible is met
Part B 20% coinsuranceCovered after the Part B deductibleYou pay it until the high deductible is met, then covered
Part B excess chargesCoveredCount toward the deductible, then covered
Most you pay for Medicare-covered care in a yearThe Part B deductibleThe full high deductible
Foreign travel emergency80% up to plan limits80% up to plan limits, with its own separate yearly deductible
Who can buy itAnyone eligible for a Medigap policyAnyone eligible, from companies that offer it in Nebraska

The short answer

Choose High-Deductible Plan G if you are healthy, can pay the full high deductible from savings without strain, and will set aside what you save on premiums. Choose regular Plan G if a big medical bill would hurt your budget or you expect regular care, surgeries or hospital stays.

High-Deductible Plan G is a trade. You take on more of the cost in a bad year, and in return you pay a much smaller premium every month. Whether that trade works depends less on the plan and more on your savings, your health and your habits.

How does High-Deductible Plan G work?

You pay Medicare-covered costs yourself until you reach the yearly deductible. CMS sets that amount each year and announces the next year's figure ahead of time; it rose again for 2027. After that, the policy pays exactly like regular Plan G for the rest of the calendar year. The deductible resets every January.

Costs that count toward the deductible are the ones regular Plan G would have paid:

  • The Part A hospital deductible, charged once per benefit period
  • The Part B deductible, charged once a year
  • Your 20% Part B coinsurance on doctor visits, tests and outpatient care
  • Part B excess charges, skilled nursing coinsurance and hospital coinsurance

Prescription drugs (that is Part D's job), dental, vision and anything else Medicare does not cover do not count. Foreign travel emergency care has its own separate yearly deductible. For the full plan details, see High-Deductible Plan G and regular Plan G.

How much lower is the premium in Nebraska?

A lot lower. The Nebraska Department of Insurance publishes 2026 premium ranges at age 65 for both plans in its Medicare Supplement Fact Sheet. Even the highest High-Deductible Plan G premium on that list is below the lowest regular Plan G premium. The Plan G range is wide because prices differ a great deal between companies, so your actual gap depends on which companies you compare.

Most Nebraska Medigap policies are attained-age rated, according to the Department of Insurance, so both premiums usually rise as you get older. Get both quotes from the same company, and ask about its rate history on each plan.

What does the math look like in a good year and a bad year?

The answer depends on the kind of year you have. Start with your yearly premium savings: subtract the HD-G monthly premium from the Plan G premium and multiply by 12. Then test that number against three kinds of year.

Kind of yearWhat you pay with regular Plan GWhat you pay with HD-GWhich comes out ahead
Quiet year: you meet only the Part B deductibleThe Part B deductibleThe Part B deductibleHD-G, by your full premium savings
Middle year: some care, but less than the high deductibleThe Part B deductibleEverything Medicare left youHD-G if your premium savings exceed the extra you paid; Plan G if not
Bad year: you reach the high deductibleThe Part B deductibleThe full high deductiblePlan G, unless your premium savings exceed the gap between the two deductibles

How the middle and bad years work: with HD-G you pay all the costs Medicare left you up to the high deductible, while with regular Plan G you pay only the Part B deductible. Subtract the Part B deductible from what you paid with HD-G. If your premium savings are bigger than that difference, HD-G still came out ahead that year.

What kind of year is "bad"? One inpatient hospital admission triggers the Part A deductible by itself. Add the 20% coinsurance on the surgeon and other doctors, and a single hospital stay can use up most or all of the deductible.

Who is High-Deductible Plan G a good fit for?

It fits healthy people with savings who would rather keep the premium difference than prepay for care they rarely use.

  • You see a doctor a few times a year and have no planned surgeries.
  • You could pay the full high deductible from savings in a bad year.
  • You will bank the premium savings, so two or three quiet years fund one bad one.
  • You built up an HSA while working. You cannot contribute once you are on Medicare, but you can spend the balance on qualified medical costs. Our page on HSAs and Medicare covers the timing rules.

Who should stick with regular Plan G?

Regular Plan G fits people who want predictable costs or expect to use care. You pay a higher premium, and your yearly cost for Medicare-covered care is just the Part B deductible.

  • You manage a chronic condition with frequent tests, specialists or infusions.
  • You have a surgery or procedure coming up.
  • A bill the size of the full high deductible would mean borrowing or putting it on a card.
  • You want no thinking about deductibles at all.

If you want a lower premium without a large deductible, compare Plan G vs Plan N, which trades small copays for a smaller discount.

What mistakes do people make with High-Deductible Plan G?

The biggest mistake is picking the high-deductible plan for the low premium and then spending the savings. The plan only works if the money is there when the bad year comes.

Other mistakes to avoid:

  1. Planning to switch to regular Plan G when health changes. By then, you may not pass the health questions. Your one-time Medigap Open Enrollment Period is the only window when Nebraska companies must accept you regardless of health, unless a guaranteed issue right applies. Nebraska has no birthday rule.
  2. Thinking drug costs count toward the deductible. They do not. You still need a Part D plan for prescriptions.
  3. Using an old deductible figure. CMS adjusts it each year, so check the current amount on Medicare.gov or in the company's materials before you run the math.
  4. Comparing only one company. Benefits are standardized, so the same plan letter covers the same things everywhere. Price and rate history are what vary. Our guide to Medicare Supplement plans explains what to compare.

Where can you get unbiased help comparing these plans?

You can compare Medigap prices by ZIP code on Medicare.gov, or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week (TTY 1-877-486-2048). Nebraska SHIP (formerly SHIIP), part of the Department of Insurance, offers one-on-one counseling at 1-800-234-7119. See SHIP and local Medicare help for more.

If you want both plans quoted from several companies and the math run on your own numbers, talk to me. My help costs you nothing.

Frequently asked questions

CMS sets it each year and raised it again for 2027; its yearly notice and Medicare.gov list the current amount. You pay that much in Medicare-covered costs that Medicare does not pay, such as the Part A and Part B deductibles and your 20% coinsurance, before the policy pays anything. After you reach it, the plan pays like regular Plan G for the rest of the calendar year.

Yes. The Part B deductible is one of the costs that counts toward the high deductible. So do the Part A hospital deductible, charged once per benefit period, Part B coinsurance and excess charges. Your Part D drug costs, dental, vision and other services Medicare does not cover do not count.

You can apply, but it is not guaranteed. Outside your one-time Medigap Open Enrollment Period and guaranteed issue situations, Nebraska companies can ask health questions and may refuse coverage because of health reasons. Nebraska has no birthday rule that allows a yearly switch. If you think you will want regular Plan G within a few years, it may be safer to start with it.

You cannot put new money into an HSA once you have Medicare, but you can keep spending the balance you built while working. IRS Publication 969 says HSA money can pay qualified medical expenses and Medicare premiums at 65 or older, but not Medigap premiums. So an existing HSA can help cover the bills that count toward your high deductible.

No. High-Deductible Plan G is a Medigap policy that works with Original Medicare, so you can see any provider in the country that accepts Medicare with no network or referrals. Medicare Advantage plans replace Original Medicare, usually use networks, and set their own copays and out-of-pocket maximums. You cannot have both at the same time.

Sources

  1. CMS: 2027 Medigap high-deductible options for Plans F, G and J (opens in a new tab)
  2. Medicare.gov: Choosing a Medigap Policy (CMS Product No. 02110, March 2026) (opens in a new tab)
  3. Nebraska Department of Insurance: Medicare Supplement Fact Sheet 2026 (opens in a new tab)
  4. CMS: 2026 Medicare Parts A and B premiums and deductibles (opens in a new tab)
  5. IRS Publication 969: Health Savings Accounts (opens in a new tab)
Bill Jurey

Bill Jurey

Independent Licensed Insurance Agent · Lincoln, Nebraska

Bill spent twenty years on manufacturing floors before getting licensed in 2017. He has helped Nebraskans with Medicare since 2020, shopping several carriers so clients get straight answers instead of a sales pitch. More about Bill

The following representation figures apply to Lancaster County, Nebraska. Representation and plan availability vary by county. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 4 organizations which offer 28 products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options. 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. TTY users can call 1-877-486-2048.

Talk to Bill

Want a straight answer about your situation?

Bring your medications and your doctors. I will lay out your options in plain English, and you decide. My help costs you nothing, and there is never any pressure.

In person in Lincoln, by phone, or by video. By appointment.

Portrait of Bill Jurey